Evaluating Company Management: Leveraging Leadership for Better Returns

It's easy to forget that every business has people at its core, like the board and management, in today's technology-driven investment world. There are real people with their own strengths, weaknesses, and emotional biases behind every business choice and plan. All these people-related factors are often just as important to the success or loss of a business as new technologies and market trends.

It's just as important to look at a company's finances as it is to know what its management and board are good at and bad at. Smart investors say that the company's ability to handle risk well, its succession planning, its governance processes, its alignment with shareholder interests, and the effectiveness of its leadership are all important factors for its success. Nevertheless, a mere skim of annual reports or earnings calls is insufficient for delving into these facets. It necessitates studying the past performance of the leadership team, analysing the policies and decisions made by the board of directors, and knowing how all these factors affect the future of the organization. This investigation will go into the best ways for investors to evaluate these crucial factors, so they can make decisions based on more than just the numbers—they can also consider the calibre of the people running the show.

If you are an investor who looks closely at management (which you should be), you should fear several things to do with management and their performance. 

Bad Leadership 

Firstly, many investors have concerns about bad leadership and decision-making. Do your research on the company's top team first, looking at how well they've done in the past. Participate in meetings and conversations with management to learn about their strategic direction and how they make decisions. KPIs and financial measures should be closely watched to get a sense of how well the company is doing. Talk to investors and experts in the field to get fair advice. If you have a big investment, you might want to get on the board so you can have a direct say in how the company grows. If leadership problems keep happening and hurt the company's success, push for change. Diversify your portfolio to mitigate the risks associated with any single company’s leadership challenges. Have an exit plan ready in case the leadership problems aren't fixed properly and continue to hurt the company's performance. Make sure that the company follows all laws and rules and keeps up with new challenges and trends in the business.

Corporate Governance

Corporate governance is paramount. A multifaceted method is necessary for investors who are worried about issues. This means getting involved with and talking to the company's management and board, using voting rights to have a say in governance decisions, and working with other investors to have a bigger voice as a group. It is very important to push for more openness and responsibility, as well as a board that has a good mix of skills, experience, and freedom. Key steps include keeping an eye on the company's governance on a regular basis, backing changes that raise governance standards, and making sure that all laws and rules are followed. Doing a full risk assessment on governance problems helps you figure out how they might affect the investment and the company's performance. If governance problems keep happening and hurt the company's worth and investment, it might be time to lower stakes or get out of the investment altogether, especially if attempts to make things better fail. To protect and increase the value of their investments, investors need to be proactive, well-informed, and ready to make smart decisions while also actively participating in these issues.

Lack of Alignment with Shareholder Interests 

So that the company's goals are aligned with those of its shareholders, owners should act. To do this, pay packages for executives need to be closely looked at to make sure they are linked to success metrics that are in line with long-term shareholder value. Investors can use their voting rights to have a say in how much executives are paid and who is appointed to the board. Having direct conversations with the board and management is important for voicing concerns and learning how they make decisions. Investors should also push for governance systems that put the needs of shareholders first. For example, policies that are good for shareholders should be put in place, and board oversight should be improved. When investors work together as a group, they can have a bigger impact on company governance issues. It is very important to keep an eye on the company's plan and performance, especially when it comes to creating long-term value versus short-term gains. If alignment problems keep happening and have a big effect on shareholder value, investors might think about working together to make bigger changes in governance or, as a last option, selling their shares in the company. To make sure that management and the board are acting in a way that benefits shareholders, this method requires being alert, actively involved, and ready to act quickly when needed.

Risk Management Failures 

Investors must deal with risk management issues in a company in a wise and thorough manner. First and foremost, investors should carefully look over the company's policies and processes for managing risk. This means knowing how the business finds, evaluates, and deals with different kinds of routine and strategic risks. It's important for investors to interact with the company's management and board. You should seek out the company calendar, go to shareholder meetings, talk to board members directly, and ask pointed questions about the company's risk management strategy and any recent events.

It is important to keep an eye on the company's success and how it handles new risks. Investors should also look at reports and assessments done by outside parties of the company's risk management. If problems are found, investors can use their power to push for better risk management through voting rights and shareholder votes. This could mean pushing for the appointment of board members with experience in risk management or pushing for the creation of a group whose sole job is to oversee risks.

Working with other owners can make your worries stronger and cause bigger changes. But if attempts to fix problems with risk management fail and the problems continue to pose a big threat to the company's value, owners should think about reevaluating their investment and possibly lowering their stake or leaving the business altogether.

Poor Succession Planning

Investors who are worried here can lower the risks that come with it in several ways. They should work together with the company's management and board, stressing how important it is to have a strong plan for who will take over key positions, like top executives and board members. This conversation can happen at shareholder meetings, through direct messages, or by taking part in investment calls.

People who own shares in a company can also use their voting rights to change how it plans for the future. This could mean voting on motions that require a clear succession plan to be made and shared, or it could mean voting for board candidates who put succession planning first and have experience doing it well.

It is very important to keep an eye on what the company says and does in public about succession planning. Investors should be able to see how the company finds and trains people who could take over key jobs in the future. In situations where succession planning isn't done well, owners can work with other shareholders to push for a more organized and clear method.

When you're investing, it's important to remember that people, from the board to the management, are at the heart of every business. Their skills, weaknesses, and personal biases are very important to how business goes. Key things to do include keeping an eye on KPIs and financial metrics, making sure that senior pay is in line with long-term shareholder value, and pushing for open governance practices. Working together with other investors can have a bigger effect, and it's important to be ready to change investment strategies if there are problems with control, risk management, or succession planning. To sum up, smart buying requires a proactive, well-informed approach that balances numbers with an assessment of the people behind the numbers.

On the date of publication, Jim Osman did not have (either directly or indirectly) positions in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.


More Related Articles

Info icon

This data feed is not available at this time.

Sign up for the TradeTalks newsletter to receive your weekly dose of trading news, trends and education. Delivered Wednesdays.