Markets

Why Finance Breeds So Much Disagreement

Source: Robert Shiller's recreation of the S&P 500, author's
calculations.

Source: Robert Shiller's recreation of the S&P 500, author's calculations.

If you were born in 1970, your impressionable youth was spent watching stocks practically go straight up. If you were born in 1950, your early years were spent watching stocks crash, recover, crash again, and over a 16-year period return pretty much nothing after inflation.

There is no way that living through these two periods didn't influence your view of the market. "Truth" is shaped by what you have experienced in life, and what you have experienced in life is entirely dependent on what year you were born.

There's also a huge variance in experiences during your working years depending on when you were born:

This was the same 1950s cohort that saw stocks go nowhere during
their early years, so they were skeptical of the stock rally until
it had gone on for years and was nearing an end. The 1930s cohort
saw stocks boom during their teens and 20s, leading to the 1960s
stock bubble that inflated confidence just in time for a two-decade
bear market.

From age 30 to 50, those born in 1930 got no return out of stocks. Those born in 1950 saw stocks rise twelvefold. These are not small differences. They implanted a completely different view on what markets are capable of.

This was the same 1950s cohort that saw stocks go nowhere during their early years, so they were skeptical of the stock rally until it had gone on for years and was nearing an end. The 1930s cohort saw stocks boom during their teens and 20s, leading to the 1960s stock bubble that inflated confidence just in time for a two-decade bear market.

In both cases, stocks probably did something during your working years that your youth taught you was unlikely to occur. That made you -- and everyone else -- confused, disoriented, argumentative, and skeptical. And that's why there's so much disagreement in finance.

There's also a big range of outcomes in stock performance during retirement years:

You can also imagine these two people going on TV to argue their
respective positions. But they're not really arguing - they're just
rehashing their unique life experience, which came from the random
chance of when they were born.

You can imagine someone born in 1885 talking about the glorious, glorious benefits of owning stocks during retirement. Or someone born in 1905 wishing they had stuck to bonds, which earned a higher return with less volatility during their own retirement.

You can also imagine these two people going on TV to argue their respective positions. But they're not really arguing - they're just rehashing their unique life experience, which came from the random chance of when they were born.

Finance is a strange subject because there are no firm rules that work all the time. This might have worked for the last two decades. That might work for the next two. But it's always changing. And since things are always changing, some people will stubbornly attach to old beliefs while others look silly as they discover new ones.

Max Planck once said, "New scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." That's also a pretty good definition of how finance works.

Check back every Tuesday and Friday for Morgan Housel's columns.

More from The Motley Fool:Warren Buffett Tells You How to Turn $40 into $10 Million

The article Why Finance Breeds So Much Disagreement originally appeared on Fool.com.

Contact Morgan Housel at mhousel@fool.com. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy .

Copyright © 1995 - 2014 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy .

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.


The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

Other Topics

Stocks