Markets

What stocks may need: a bit of inflation

Aaron Burden / Getty Images

Back in February I highlighted the interesting--read: troubling--divergence between stock prices and bond yields. Bonds were signaling an economic slowdown while persistent equity gains suggested a near perfect balance between growth and low inflation. Since then the divergence has only widened.

Equities hit a five-month high late last week, while bond yields fell to their lowest level since January of 2018. To be sure, much of the recent drop in interest rates reflects a rapid shift in Federal Reserve policy, one that suggests an abrupt end to the Fed’s tightening cycle. That said, with a dovish Fed already reflected in both bond and equity markets, can this divergence continue?

In answering the question, it is helpful to focus on one particular aspect of interest rates: inflation expectations. Nominal interest rates can be broken down into a real, or after-inflation component, and inflation expectations, captured by the break-even (BE) rate in Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS).

In the post-crisis environment long-term BE rates (derived from the 10-Year TIP) and U.S. equities have been closely correlated. Weekly changes in 10 Yr. BE’s have explained nearly 30% of the variation in S&P 500 returns (see Chart). To my mind this makes sense. In the post-crisis environment investors have constantly been worried about too little growth. In this context a positive relationship between inflation expectations, which are driven by growth, and stocks is intuitive.

However, since late November there has been a pretty significant divergence between stocks and BE rates. While inflation expectations have recovered from the December bottom, the 10-year BE is basically flat compared to where it was around Thanksgiving. During the same period, however, the S&P 500 has gained roughly 8.5%. Most of this divergence occurred in the immediate aftermath of the December low, but in recent weeks it has re-emerged. Inflation expectations have been flat during the past month while the S&P 500 has rallied another 2.5%.

A little inflation can be a good thing

Going forward, to the extent break-evens are flat-to-lower this calls the longevity of the rally into question. Why should this be the case? In one word: margins. Historically, higher inflation expectations have been associated with higher profit margins. This is because companies can enjoy better pricing power, and better margins, when inflation expectations are higher. This relationship is evident in the data.

During the past 20 years profit margins have averaged 6.5% in periods of below-average inflation expectations, defined as less than 2%. However, in periods when inflation expectations have been above average profit margins have averaged over 8%.

To the extent higher inflation expectations are associated with higher pricing power and better margins, a drop in inflation expectations would be another data point suggesting that the divergence between rates and stocks cannot go on forever. Either bond yields are too low or investors should be more nervous about earnings than they seem to be.

Russ Koesterich, CFA, is Portfolio Manager for BlackRock's Global Allocation team and is a regular contributor to The Blog.

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

Latest Markets Videos

    BlackRock

    BlackRock offers breadth of capabilities - and depth of knowledge – across active and passive strategies, including iShares® ETFs. This is combined with a singular focus on delivering strong, consistent performance and an ability to look across asset classes, geographies and investment strategies to find the right solutions.

    Learn More