Wal-Mart(NYSE:WMT) reported weaker-than-expected fiscal Q1 2014 results due to a 1.4% decline in US comparable store sales. The Company earned $1.14 per share, missing street expectations of $1.15 per share. Additionally, revenue of $114.19 billion fell shy of analyst estimates of $116.29 billion.
Decline in US same store sales can be mainly attributed to weak consumer spending during the quarter primarily caused by payroll tax increase — As of January 1, 2013, payroll taxes in the US increased by 2%, which hurt the lower and middle income segment consumers. Since, a majority of Wal-Mart's customers lie within this demographic; Wal-Mart's revenue and Earnings suffered due to the tax hike.
Other reasons that contributed towards a disappointing quarter are as follows:
- Delay in tax refunds — 2012 tax refunds were delayed due to year-end complications related to the fiscal cliff. Since, the IRS delayed the filing process by 15 days, refund checks came later than usual.
- Prolonged cold weather impacted sales of weather-sensitive products 1.
- Revenues suffered due to lower-than-expected price inflation of grocery items, which account for more than 50% of Wal-Mart's revenues.
However, despite a disappointing quarter, there were some underlying positives for the retail behemoth. Key positive highlights include:
- Wal-Mart exhibited encouraging market share metrics across several categories including food, consumables, and health and wellness OTC products 2.
- Driven by strong e-commerce growth, Wal-Mart continued gaining market share in major international markets and generated positive comparable store sales growth, which resulted in overall revenue from international locations to increase by 5.4% during the quarter.
- The Company maintained stringent cost control over its operating expenses 3 despite of an increase in operating revenues and corporate expenses.
The retail giant has been in the midst of controversy lately. The company is currently embroiled in lawsuits with the US Justice Department over a bribery scandal in Mexico. As a result, the Company spent $73 million on expenses associated with those reviews.
Most recently, labour and consumer groups have been pressuring Wal-Mart to take steps to ensure factory safety in Bangladesh, where it produces many of its goods and where a building collapse in April killed more than 1,000 workers. While Wal-Mart announced it would not join a broad factory safety plan supported by H&M and other large retailers, it would pursue its own plan, including conducting inspections of the 279 Bangladeshi factories it uses.
While, these issues are unlikely to impact Company financials in the long run, it may be a bit of an overhang for the stock price in the short run.
The above Quality - Value chart consists of the following companies: Wal-Mart (NYSE:WMT), Costco Wholesale Corporation (NASDAQ:COST), PriceSmart Inc. (NASDAQ:PSMT), and Companhia Brasileira de Distribuicao. (NYSE:CBD).
Based on Market IQ's Valuation metrics, Wal-Mart is cheaper than 88% of its peers and offers compelling Fundamental metrics that justify investment in the retailer (see below).
The Company's Qualitative strength can be seen in multiple areas such as Return on Equity (ROE) and EPS growth.
- ROE increased to 22.27% in fiscal Q1 2014 vs. 22% in fiscal Q1 2013. Additionally, Wal-Mart offers a higher ROE when compared to the industry average of 18.11%.
- The company has demonstrated a pattern of positive earnings per share growth over the past two years. During the past fiscal year, Wal-Mart increased its bottom line by earning $5.02 vs. $4.55 in the prior year. This year, the market expects an improvement in earnings ($5.30 vs. $5.02).
Additionally, Market IQ's Relative Risk metrics suggest that Wal-Mart is likely to provide a smoother ride in terms of price volatility especially during current turbulent times when there is a lot of anxiety among investors after the FOMC indicated that the Federal Reserve might begin tapering its asset purchases later this year. High market Capitalization, historically stable earnings variability, cheap Valuation metrics, and insensitivity to business cycles and credit spreads make Wal-Mart significantly less risky relative to other companies (see below).
Wal-Mart is attempting to play catch-up with Amazon in e-commerce, which will likely help the Company achieve sales growth. Wal-Mart is looking to integrate its stores and e-commerce channel to provide a seamless shopping experience. Wal-Mart will also soon start offering gift cards and mobile coupons along with its "Scan & Go" service. Although online sales account for a small portion of Wal-Mart's revenues, its vast customer base will likely help the Company tap the growth opportunity in online retail.
Going forward, management is optimistic about Company operations and profitability as impact from weather and tax related issues that affected Q1 results are likely to fade. In addition, the Company expects to improve its comparable sales growth in US.
While, there are short-term headwinds facing the Company, Wal-Mart's growth prospects, sound fundamentals, and growing dividend stream 4, present a foundational holding for the dividend growth investor's portfolio.
1Sales of warm-weather items, from outdoor furniture and sporting goods to fans and spring clothes, were challenged, particularly from mid-March to mid-April 2013.
2According to the Nielsen Company, Wal-Mart gained 20 basis points of market share in the measured category of "food, consumables and health and wellness/OTC" during the 13 weeks ending April 27, 2013.
3Consolidated operating expenses as a percentage of net sales remained roughly flat despite just 1% growth in revenues and a 44.4% increase in corporate and support expenses
4Wal-Mart has increased dividends for the past 15 years with its current dividend yield standing at 2.4%.
This commentary is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The opinions offered herein are not recommendations to buy, sell or hold securities. Market IQ expressly disclaims all liability in respect to actions taken based on any or all of the information on this writing.