Spike in U.S. mortgage activity catches big banks flat footed
By Imani Moise
Oct 18 (Reuters) - A surge in U.S. mortgage applications has left Bank of America Corp BAC.N, Wells Fargo & Co WFC.N and other large banks scrambling to meet demand, leading to longer closing times and unhappy customers.
The industry has faced an unexpected swell of demand since the U.S. Federal Reserve began cutting interest rates in July, bankers and industry analysts said. Lenders do not have enough staff to process requests, due to years of job cuts when rates were rising, they said.
Bank of America, one of the largest U.S. mortgage originators, now takes 41 days, on average, to close a purchase loan, a person familiar with the matter said. Refinancing has climbed to 60 days, another source said.
Both are longer than the 30 days realtors and borrowers ordinarily expect to complete a loan, but sources inside the bank said timings are not out of line with rivals.
Reuters could not obtain Wells Fargo's average closing times, but a person familiar with its mortgage business said some loans were taking more than 120 days to close.
Wells Fargo spokesman Tom Goyda said the average closing time for purchase loans has remained stable this year but acknowledged the average closing time for refinance loans has increased.
The bank recently announced hiring plans to deal with the backlog.
"Wells Fargo Home Lending is working to provide a great experience for our customers and meet their expectations during this period of increased demand," Goyda said.
Getting a mortgage is a notoriously complicated process, even when rates are stable and banks are amply staffed.
Borrowers must provide reams of documents to meet standards set by banks and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-backed providers of mortgage financing. They also need cooperation from lenders, realtors, appraisers and title companies.
Sudden spikes in demand can make matters worse.
Mortgage applications have increased most weeks since the Fed began cutting rates, according to a Mortgage Bankers Association index. Bank of America, Wells Fargo and JPMorgan Chase & Co JPM.N reported big jumps in mortgage originations, of 26-58%, when reporting quarterly results this week.
Donnie Keller, a real estate agent from Fort Worth, Texas, said he has had such bad experiences lately with Bank of America that he now cautions his customers against taking out a mortgage there. The bank's slowness has created headaches for borrowers, some of whom have lost out on dream homes, Keller said.
"They continue to over-promise and under-deliver," he said in an interview.
His frustrations echo complaints from half a dozen real estate agents in New York, New Jersey, North Carolina and California. They told Reuters delays in mortgage closings have hurt borrowers, highlighting Bank of America and Wells Fargo in particular.
"They have low interest rates, they get the buyers in and then they just completely destroy the deal," said Cara Campos, a realtor in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.
The problem is not lost on the banks.
Bank of America has begun hiring mortgage staff and extended its interest-rate lock period from 60 to 90 days, a person familiar with its mortgage business said. That "lock" guarantees a customer a certain price, even if rates fluctuate while a loan is being processed.
Wells Fargo raised its refinancing lock period twice this year before rates started dropping, according to internal memos. That time frame was at 120 days as of June.
In addition to hiring, the bank is offering underwriters unlimited overtime pay as an incentive to work through the backlog, a source in the business told Reuters.
Its mortgage staffing is already up 10% from last year, Goyda said. The bank is now advertising more than 100 positions with "mortgage" in the title, according to business data tracker Thinknum.
Banks may find it hard to accomplish mortgage-staffing goals because of a strong U.S. job market and the business' reputation for volatile employment.
Mortgage-loan officer applications fell 36% in the first quarter, according to the most recent data from the Conference of State Bank Supervisors. The number of people leaving the industry jumped 56%.
Lenders want to rely more on digital options to reduce staffing fluctuations and delays, much like non-bank rival Quicken Loans. Quicken has become the No. 2 U.S. mortgage lender in a little over a decade because of the ease with which borrowers can get loans processed quickly online. (http://reut.rs/21jMCEH)
The rise of digital lending has helped lower overall closing times. The time it takes to close on a new home has fallen from 74 days in 2017 to 43 days in August, according to Lending Tree data. Refinancings took 46 days on average.
"Manual stuff doesn't scale well with huge volume spikes," said Nima Ghamsari, chief executive of Blend Labs Inc, a mortgage software startup. "I don't think anyone predicted the rate environment that we are in six to nine months ago."
(Reporting by Imani Moise Editing by Lauren Tara LaCapra and Tom Brown)