Aphria Stock Investors Balk At the Fine Print of Green Growth’s Offer

An image of people surrounding a sheet of paper with many charts on it Credit: Shutterstock photo

InvestorPlace - Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips

On Thursday, relatively new legal marijuana player Green Growth Brands (OTCQB: GGBXF ) offered to swap GGBXF shares for all outstanding shares of Aphria (NYSE: APHA ), suggesting the offer was worth $11.00 (Canadian, or roughly $8 in U.S. dollars) per share of Aphria stock. All told, the suitor says the proposed deal values Aphria at $2.8 billion in Canadian currency, or $2.1 billion in U.S. dollars.

Investors thus far are facing mixed feelings on the matter.

The news sent Aphria shares up by more than 18% in after-hours trading, and APHA stock was still up nearly 14% on Friday morning … a big move by almost any standard. Yet, it's also a disappointment to most APHA shareholders, given the stock's early November peak of $17.60 (Canadian, or $13.45 in the U.S.). Just as disappointing is how, even with the big gain, Aphria stock remains miles away from Green Growth's touted suggested value for Aphria shares, with NYSE-listed shares only trading near $6.30. Trading of its Toronto-listing remains halted, though it isn't apt to be any more impressive once trading resumes either.

The muted response is largely the result of a small but important detail of the offer. Also holding the rally back, though, may be an unvoiced lack of confidence in either company's prospects, separate, or together.

Details of the Deal

On the surface, the offer to owners of Aphria stock looks typical. Green Growth is prepared to hand over 1.5714 shares of GGBXF for every one share of APHA stock investors are willing to turn in. The all-stock offer, according to Green Growth Brands' press release, represents a 45% premium to the Dec. 24 closing price of APHA stock, which in turn translates into a mathematical valuation of $2.1 billion (or $2.8 billion in Canadian dollars) for Aphria Inc.

A careful, second read of Green Growth's all-stock pitch, however, reveals a critical detail that may have been overlooked with the first read. That is, the implied $2.1 billion (U.S.) valuation assumes a price $7 per share of Green Growth Brands stock. That's not where its shares have been trading of late.

An official response from Aphria explains :

"Based on the 20-day volume weighted average price of GGB shares and the expressed exchange ratio of 1.5714 common shares of GGB for each Aphria share, the proposed bid would be approximately 23% below the Company's average share price over the same period. Aphria shareholders should be aware that the value of GGB's per-share offer is based on a hypothetical valuation of its own shares, with no relation to the current price."

As is so often the case, the market already knew it before Aphria said it. Neither the Canadian-listed or U.S.-listed version of Aphria stock moved anywhere near Green Growth's suggested per-share buyout value.

Dealmaking Opportunities Drying Up?

It would be anything but a game-changing pairing of two titans within the marijuana/hemp industry; much bigger deals have taken shape this year.

Case(s) in point: In August, Constellation Brands (NYSE: STZ ) made a $4 billion investment in Canopy Growth (NYSE: CGC ). In December, Altria Group (NYSE: MO ) shelled out $1.8 billion for a 45% stake in Cronos Group (NASDAQ: CRON ). Although not equity-based deals, the marijuana industry has also seen major supply deals inked by Tilray (NASDAQ: TLRY ) and others. Even beverage behemoth Coca-Cola (NYSE: KO ) has acknowledged its mulling of cannabis-infused beverages .

Aphria and Green Growth Brands, in comparison, aren't nearly as well-known (or as well-funded) as any of those names … even within cannabis circles.

For Green Growth, the reason is, the company didn't exist as a publicly traded marijuana play until a reverse takeover with Xanthic Biopharma was completed earlier this year (a reverse takeover as a way for a company to become publicly traded without the hassle of an IPO, establishing an easy way for it to raise funds).

As for Aphria, it wasn't traded on an American exchange until November of this year . And, until last year, the Canadian company's stock was only available through Toronto's riskier "venture" exchange or through the United States' OTC exchange.

The rapid rise of lesser-known names in the business - and now their sudden interest in dealmaking - is a subtle hint that the medical marijuana and hemp business is starting to gel, but gelling in a way that is quickly shutting new and smaller players out.

As cannabis has been legitimized and at least some of these companies have become profitable, financial backers and investors have become pickier. They can afford to be. They have to be, in fact, and it's not clear that combining these two lesser companies will make for one viable company that can compete with better-established names like Tilray and Canopy Growth, or their partners. And, as time marches on, the industry's M&A will be less and less compelling; the top names in any business tend to be snatched up first, or are locked up with exclusivity agreements.

We may have already reached the point within the cannabis industry's life where buyout options are thin, and unimpressive.

Aphria Stock Capped, For Now

As it stands right now, neither Aphria's shareholders nor Green Growth Brands' investors are convinced the underlying potential of the pairing justifies the offer's numbers (GGBXF stock is also well below Green Growth's value estimate). If anything, investors are viewing the proposal as little more than a lowball offer based on some creative number-crunching.

The current scenario doesn't preclude a better offer, to be clear. It's also possible GGBXF could recover recently lost value and become the basis an offer Aphria shareholders are unable to refuse. Indeed, Green Growth's argument that "Together, we can unleash synergies between our teams, assets and geographies, forming a combined enterprise that will accelerate our collective growth strategies" actually holds some water, and in time Aphria's investors may believe the pairing is the only viable option.

If a deal is going to get done, however, it's unlikely it will get done unless something dramatic changes. What those changes might be is anyone's guess.

As of this writing, James Brumley did not hold a position in any of the aforementioned securities. You can follow him on Twitter , at @jbrumley.

More From InvestorPlace

Compare Brokers

The post Aphria Stock Investors Balk At the Fine Print of Green Growth's Offer appeared first on InvestorPlace .

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

More Related Articles

Sign up for Smart Investing to get the latest news, strategies and tips to help you invest smarter.