U.S. home prices have risen by more than 30% since bottoming
out in early 2012, so it's a valid argument to say that owning
a home is expensive compared with just a few years ago.
However, that doesn't necessarily mean renting is a better
option -- both buying and renting have their own pros and cons.
We asked three of our writers which is the best option as we
head into 2016, and here's what they had to say.
: There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but for many people,
renting makes more sense these days than buying. For some
people, the choice is very clear: Buying a home can be more
costly, given the cost of the purchase itself, plus taxes and
insurance, plus maintenance and repairs. If buying the kind of
home you want would be tough on you financially -- or
impossible -- then rent. Renting is also sensible if you don't
expect to be in the home for too long. If you think you might
be selling the home within a few years, you stand a good chance
of losing money on the deal, because of the closing costs, the
possible drop in the value of your home, and the money that you
put into setting up the house the way you want it and then
spiffing it up later to be shown and sold.
Where you plan to buy should also factor into your decision,
as buying makes more sense in some regions, while renting does
in others. The real estate research firm RealtyTrac compiles
data on such things across 285 major counties, and it most
recently found that buying was more cost effective than renting
in 66% of them, but that leaves many counties where renting is
best. Among the counties where buying is less cost-effective
are Los Angeles, San Diego, and Orange, Calif.; King, Wash. (in
the Seattle metro area); and Denver, Colo.
The Beracha, Hardin & Johnson Buy vs. Rent Index,
produced by researchers at Florida Atlantic
University and Florida International University, also
favors renting for many people: "According to the latest
BH&J Index, as of the end of the first quarter of 2015, the
housing market in the U.S. and all cities in the index are
trending either closer to renting being the superior option or
strictly favoring renting over purchasing a home."
Your mileage may vary, so think about your particular
situation, your financial health and goals, as you decide
whether to rent or buy.
I think all three writers here can agree that there is no
single answer to this question. However, I feel that buying a
home is a better move than renting in the vast majority of
For starters, rent is getting less and less affordable.
, the median asking price of rental property in the U.S. is
$1,575 per month, while the mortgage payment on a median-priced
($180,100) home would be just over $850 at the current low
interest rates. Even with taxes, insurance, and maintenance,
it's tough to make a financial case in favor of renting.
Additionally, buying a home locks in your housing payment
for an extended period of time. Even if you find a rental
property that will cost you the same amount per month as a
purchase, consider that rent has historically risen by about 5%
per year. So, an apartment that costs $1,500 per month to rent
today can be expected to cost more than $2,600 in 20 years.
Meanwhile, your $1,500 mortgage payment will still be the same
Finally, of course there are the additional benefits of
building equity over time, pride of ownership, freedom to
customize, etc. These are all excellent reasons to buy a home,
but I think the financial case alone is pretty compelling in
the current real estate market.
: Matt and Selena have already indicated it does depend on your
situation and location, so here's some food for thought on
determining what makes the most sense for you.
Buying a house isn't going to make you rich. Home values
have -- since the post-WWII housing boom started 70 years ago
-- more or less kept up with inflation, meaning there are much
better ways to grow your wealth, such as investing in
However, the biggest benefit to buying is this: You get to
stop the clock on the majority of your housing costs. There's
almost no chance you'll be able to fix rental costs for more
than a year -- maybe two -- in most markets.
Can you imagine paying the same rent payment for 30 years?
That's the real power of buying a home.
But there's a risk to buying if you can't stay put for the
long- term: Millions of homeowners after the recession were
unable to relocate even for the prospect of better work and
increased pay, because short-term housing value drops left them
owing more than their homes were worth. The situation was
exacerbated by the housing crash, but taking on the risk of
losing money (you'll give 6% to a Realtor when you sell) with
limited upside may not be worth it in the long run; especially
when you factor in the additional costs and responsibility of
In summary, buy a home if you plan to live in it for years.
Your home should be a place of safety and comfort, not an
albatross. Yes, the sooner you can buy and hold, the better,
but if it limits your mobility and prospects, you may be better
off renting until you're more stable and financially
How one Seattle couple secured a $60K Social Security
bonus -- and you can too
A Seattle couple recently discovered some little-known Social
Security secrets that can boost many retirees' income by as
much as $60,000. They were shocked by how easy it was to
actually take advantage of these loopholes. And although it
may seem too good to be true, it's 100% real. In fact, one
MarketWatch reporter argues that if more Americans used them,
the government would have to shell out an extra $10
billion... every year! So once you learn how to take
advantage of these loopholes, you could retire confidently
with the peace of mind we're all after, even if you're
Simply click here to receive your free copy
of our new report
that details how you can take advantage of these
Buy or Rent? What's the Best Option for
originally appeared on Fool.com.
Try any of our Foolish newsletter services
free for 30 days
. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all
considering a diverse range of insights
makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a
Copyright © 1995 - 2015 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved. The Motley Fool has a