Quantcast

7 Reasons That 3M's Guidance Looks Overly Optimistic


When management speaks, investors listen, and when it gives long-term guidance, the first thing investors do is bake the numbers into their valuations of the stock. With this point in mind, it's worth taking a close look at what 3M (NYSE: MMM) management just outlined for the next five years. Given the stock's current premium valuation, it's important for 3M to hit its guidance, and it looks like that might be a big   ask.

3M investor day guidance

Let's start by comparing the current 2019-2023 guidance with the 2016-2020 guidance given in the spring of 2016. As you can see below, on a total company basis, the current five-year outlook is pretty similar to that given a couple of years ago. There are some differences on a segment level, but the key segments to focus on, namely healthcare and consumer, have pretty similar outlooks.

Organic Sales Growth Guidance in Local Currency

Current 2019-2023 Guidance

Guidance Given for 2016-2020

Industrial

3%-5%

2%-4%

Safety and graphics

3%-6%

2%-5%

Healthcare

4%-6%

4%-6%

Electronics and energy

2%-6%

0%-4%

Consumer

2%-4%

3%-5%

Company total

3%-5%

2%-5%

Data source: 3M Company presentations.

It looks good from an organic growth perspective, and it gets better when you go into the details of the 2019-2023 plan:

  • Operating margin expansion of 200 to 300 basis points, with 100 to 200 basis points coming from gross margin expansion, and 100 basis points from selling, general, and administrative (SG&A) efficiency.
  • Acquisitions to add 1% to 3% to earning-per-share growth.
  • Free cash flow conversion from net income of 100%.
  • EPS growth of 8% to 11%.

So on a superficial level, investors are looking at a Dividend Aristocrat ( 3M has increased its dividend every year for six decades) aiming for double-digit earnings growth, with margin expansion prospects, and currently sporting a 2.6% dividend yield. All of these factors are likely why 3M trades at a valuation premium to its peers.

MMM EV to EBITDA (Forward) Chart

MMM EV to EBITDA (Forward) data by YCharts

However, the justification for the premium rating and the guidance above needs to be questioned. There are seven reasons why.

Recent sales performance has disappointed

First, the company's recent track record versus its full-year guidance hasn't exactly been great. As you can see below, the U.S. industrial recession of 2015-2016 hit 3M's sales growth hard, and it's only in the recovery year of 2017 that the company exceeded the high point of its initial full-year guidance.

3M Guidance vs. Actual Sales Growth

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018 Est.

2019 Est.

Organic local-currency growth (decline)

4.9%

1.3%

(0.1%)

5.2%

3%*

N/A

Initial guidance

3%-6%

3%-6%

1%-3% 1%-3% 3%-5% 2%-4%

Data source: 3M Company presentations. *Guidance on third-quarter 2018 earnings presentations.

Second, as you can see in the table above, this year has proved to be a disappointment so far for 3M, with growth set to come at the low end of initial guidance -- not an impressive performance in a year when U.S. industrial production is expected to grow at 3.7%, compared with 1.6% in 2017.

Third, it's worth noting that the guidance for 2019 calls for 2% to 4% organic local-currency growth. In other words, based on the midpoint of guidance, 3M expects to start the first year of its five-year plan with sales at the low end of its 3%-to-5% long-term range.

Growth hiccups

Fourth, the company prides itself on growing sales more than global industrial production and GDP, but that certainly wasn't the case in 2015 and 2016 (global industrial production grew on a monthly average of 1.8% year-on-year in the period), and it won't be the case in 2018 either. This calls into question 3M's assumption that it will grow organic local currency sales at 3% to 5% versus global industrial production growth of 2% to 3% in the 2019-2023 period.

Fifth, if 3M is going to expand gross margin and hit its sales growth targets, then it's going to have to demonstrate it can grow organic volume and organic price at the same time. Performance in recent years suggests that it's a trade-off between volume and pricing . In other words, 3M's products may not have the pricing power necessary to grow sales and margin.

A chalkboard drawing of a pair of scales weighing up risk and reward

Image source: Getty Images.

Cyclical headwinds and underperforming segments

Sixth, the healthcare and consumer segments have consistently underperformed the 2016-2020 targets . This is disappointing in itself, but consider that healthcare is 3M's least-cyclical segment, and economic growth is set to slow next year. In other words, 3M's cyclical businesses --- electronics and energy, and industrial (both have significant automotive exposure) -- could come under pressure in 2019, so 3M will need healthcare to perform better.

Seventh, let's focus on the consumer segment. Around 30% of the segment's sales come from its stationery & office supplies business, and the problem here is that its traditional customers appear to be facing structural challenges as the industry moves online. Moreover, any slowdown in the housing market will hurt 3M's construction and home improvement business -- they represent 42% of consumer segment sales.

What it means for investors

3M is a company with an admirable track record of generating returns for investors, and if you are looking for a relatively safe dividend with a management team committed to increasing it, then 3M is a good choice for income-focused investors.

On the other hand, its earnings guidance looks optimistic given ongoing underperformance of its healthcare and consumer segments and some possible pressure on its cyclically aligned segments (electronics & industrial ) in 2019. Given the lofty valuation, there's little room for error going forward. On a risk/reward basis, the stock is worth avoiding.

10 stocks we like better than 3M
When investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor , has quadrupled the market.*

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and 3M wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

Click here to learn about these picks!

*Stock Advisor returns as of November 14, 2018

Lee Samaha owns shares of Honeywell International. The Motley Fool recommends 3M. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy .

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.



This article appears in: Personal Finance , Stocks
Referenced Symbols: MMM , UTX , HON , LECO , DOV



More from Motley Fool

Subscribe






Motley Fool
Contributor:

Motley Fool

Market News, Investing










Research Brokers before you trade

Want to trade FX?