Bruce Schrader
submits:
Introduction
In recent months, a few contributors have written about ARM
Holdings plc (LSE:ARM, in the United States as an ADR
NASDAQ:[[ARMH]]); they have mostly focused on the use of ARM chips
in 'hot' technology (see e.g.
Greentech Media
).
Each of these articles is a good read and drives home the point
that ARM chips are in a lot of devices. However, today, I would
like to take a slightly broader view and look at ARM as a whole
taking a little closer look at the company's financials. SPOILER
ALERT: despite its 70x trailing 12 month earnings I still think you
can make money on ARM.
About ARM
ARM designs what is called "system-on-a-chip"; which means,
unlike in your computer, all the computing is done directly on the
chip (this is not how a typical Intel Corporation (
INTC
) chip works, the technological specifics are beyond the scope of
this article.)
There are two important facets of the above comment.
First, is the concept that everything is done on the chip. This
means that devices can be made smaller and more energy efficient.
Therefore many companies, such as
Apple Inc. (
AAPL
)
, Nintendo Co., Ltd (TYO:7974, as an ADR in the US
PINK:[[NTDOY.PK]]), GPS manufacturers (Garmin Ltd. (
GRMN
), Tom Tom etc.), and ebook manufacturers (Kindle, Sony (TYO: 6758,
NYSE: [[SNE]]) and Barnes & Noble (
BKS
)) all use ARM technology. A less than complete list of devices
that can be found on
ARM's website
(it is a long list).
Second, and what I consider most important, is that ARM
designs
the chips. They don't
make
the chips. This means the costs to ARM are low, the return on
capital is solid and the cash flow is excellent. ARM passes the
cost and complexity of manufacture to others.
Essentially all of the revenue ARM generates is either going to
selling additional chips (either R&D or SG&A) or it is
going right to the bottom line; this ability to generate cash flow
is what makes ARM such an interesting company, especially compared
to its peers. Add to this growth and you find a nearly perfect
company, which if priced right could be a perfect investment
opportunity.
In other words, when my Mac
'fanboy'
friends bought the iPad a portion of that sale went right to ARM;
likewise a portion of the sale of their new iPhone 4 will go right
to ARM. If your friends are not Mac fanboys they may be gamers, and
luckily Nintendo is coming out with a new Nintendo 3DS, which
according to many
will, as did the previous system, use an ARM chip. Just as the iPod
created a mini music revolution, Amazon.com, Inc.'s (
AMZN
) Kindle is creating a reading revolution, so if your friends are
not fanboys or gamers they'll likely own a Kindle, which of course
uses the ARM chip. Even my 4-year-old niece owns an ARM chip in her
Leapster by LeapFrog Enterprises, Inc. (
LF
). The point is pretty soon everyone will be walking around with at
least one ARM chip and each of these chips makes ARM that much more
of a compelling story.
The Numbers
Starting with what I have discussed already.
(1) ARM is a growth story. From FY05 to FY09 it has increased
the number of licenses it has sold by an average annual rate of
13%. This means, on average, the number of t
ypes
of devices that use the ARM chip increased by 13% per year.
Likewise the number of actual devices that use the ARM chip has
increased on average by 23% per year. This average is more
remarkable given that in the last year FY09 (e.g. coming off the
recession) the sales of devices with ARM chips were flat. All this
has led to an increase in dividends of, on average, 30% YoY from
FY05 to FY09.
(2) ARM is a cash flow story. As noted above, ARM's sole
function is to research and sell its technology. Therefore the
company has been able to maintain remarkably high gross margins.
Last year, FY09, the gross margin was 91.6%, and has shown
consistent improvement over the last 5 years. This allowed the
company, in FY09, to generate over 7 pence a share in cash flow
from operations. This CFO provides a large cushion for their 2.5
pence dividend in FY09. Additionally, just over 8.6 pence/share is
reinvested in ARM in the form of R&D. Given the high level of
growth ARM has recently seen, management's choice to reinvest in
the company is the logical one. The only black spot is that ARM has
recently trended toward holding cash in short term investments. In
FY08 ARM had nearly nothing invested in short term investments,
however for FY09 this trend reversed and now the company has
invested over £105M. Worst yet, the company is making a paltry 1.6%
return on these investments. For the latest quarter this investment
trend has continued as more than £40M has been added to the short
term investment account.
(3) Despite a slow year ARM, in FY09 was able to generate a ROIC
(as calculated by income before tax divided by equity less cash and
cash equivalents) of over 9%. Likewise in FY08, when earnings were
better, the ROIC was nearly 11%.
Investing in ARM is appealing for additional reasons:
Earnings
ARM generates its earnings in one of two ways. It grants
licenses so that other companies can use the ARM chipset. These are
onetime fees charged to companies that wish to use an ARM Chip. ARM
also takes in, as a royalty, a payment each time an ARM chip is
made. The size of the royalty and the license payment are
negotiated with each customer. Although it has been decreasing
recently, for each new license granted ARM has received on average
£1.5M. ARM has stated that it uses these large upfront payments to
help offset R&D and the SG&A. Therefore as more licenses
are granted (up 13% from last year) ARM is able to reduce its
licensing fee and still offset the R&D/SG&A expenses.
The royalty fees are what make ARM really shine. Unlike the
license fees which are one time only, the royalty fees are received
every time someone buys a product with an ARM chip. And because of
the way technology works, the device manufacturer would need to
introduce a new generation before switching away from the ARM chip.
To be clear, unless Amazon makes a new generation Kindle, they are
stuck using the ARM chip; the technology itself creates a barrier
that protects market share.
The chart below shows that the average royalty ARM receives is
around 4p/chip.
|
|
2005
|
2006
|
2007
|
2008
|
2009
|
|
Royalty Revenue (m)
|
87.8
|
107.8
|
104.1
|
147.7
|
155.4
|
|
chips (m)
|
1700
|
2400
|
2900
|
4000
|
3900
|
|
Revenue/chip
|
0.051
|
0.044
|
0.035
|
0.036
|
0.039
|
The royalty revenue per chip has been decreasing from 2005 to
2008, however has ticked up in the last year, in part due to a new
chip which ARM can charge a higher royalty for.
ARM has been able to grow its earnings based on the number of
ARM chips in use. The number of chips in use has increased because
of the number of devices being purchased and because the newer
devices being purchased contain more chips. Where a simple mobile
phone requires one chip, the more advanced smart phones require 5
or 6 chips, meaning ARM's royalty revenue is 6x greater for those
phones. With a secular shift to smart phones ARM should continue to
see growth.
ARM expects that by 2014, 29B chips will be shipped in the
segment. ARM currently has a 25% market share. Assuming the trends
of the past continue and that ARM is correct about its 29B
estimate, ARM should be trading at approximately 338.50 pence.
Based on the current price of 270.50 pence, purchasing ARM now
provides you with a 25% margin of safety.
(I have projected ARM's earnings based on the trend in chip
sales, royalties and margins)
|
Base Case
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2008
|
2009
|
2010E
|
2011E
|
2012E
|
2013E
|
2014E
|
|
|
Revenue
|
298,934
|
305,022
|
348,957
|
399,390
|
449,707
|
501,777
|
555,020
|
|
|
Cost of Revenue
|
-32,878
|
-25,471
|
-39,236
|
-42,270
|
-44,820
|
-46,850
|
-51,028
|
|
|
Gross profit
|
266,056
|
279,551
|
309,720
|
357,120
|
404,887
|
454,927
|
503,993
|
|
|
R&D
|
-87,588
|
-112,215
|
-115,156
|
-131,799
|
-148,403
|
-165,586
|
-183,157
|
|
|
SG&A
|
-118,525
|
-121,722
|
-139,583
|
-159,756
|
-179,883
|
-200,711
|
-222,008
|
|
|
Total operating expenses
|
-206,113
|
-233,937
|
-254,738
|
-291,555
|
-328,286
|
-366,297
|
-405,165
|
|
|
Profit from operations
|
59,943
|
45,614
|
54,982
|
65,566
|
76,601
|
88,630
|
98,828
|
|
|
Other
|
3,246
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
|
|
Profit before tax
|
63,189
|
47,259
|
56,627
|
67,211
|
78,246
|
90,275
|
100,473
|
|
|
Tax
|
-19,597
|
-6,820
|
-14,157
|
-16,803
|
-19,562
|
-22,569
|
-25,118
|
|
|
Profit for the year
|
43,592
|
40,439
|
42,470
|
50,408
|
58,685
|
67,706
|
75,355
|
|
|
Average Number of Shares
|
1,265,237
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
Terminal Value
|
|
EPS
|
3.40
|
3.20
|
3.35
|
3.98
|
4.63
|
5.35
|
5.95
|
318.27
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Discounted value
|
338.43
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Current Price
|
270.5
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Margin of Safety
|
25%
|
*This assume a 4.5% discount rate and that after 2014 ARM
grows with inflation at 3%.*
As a reality check, if ARM's market share remains constant but
keeping everything else the same ARM still appears to be about 14%
undervalued.
|
Conservative Case
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2008
|
2009
|
2010E
|
2011E
|
2012E
|
2013E
|
2014E
|
|
|
Rrevenue
|
298,934
|
305,022
|
341,477
|
383,065
|
410,373
|
465,617
|
521,101
|
|
|
Cost of Revenue
|
-32,878
|
-25,471
|
-39,236
|
-42,270
|
-44,820
|
-46,850
|
-51,028
|
|
|
Gross profit
|
266,056
|
279,551
|
302,241
|
340,796
|
365,553
|
418,767
|
470,074
|
|
|
R&D
|
-87,588
|
-112,215
|
-112,687
|
-126,412
|
-135,423
|
-153,654
|
-171,963
|
|
|
SG&A
|
-118,525
|
-121,722
|
-136,591
|
-153,226
|
-164,149
|
-186,247
|
-208,440
|
|
|
Total operating expenses
|
-206,113
|
-233,937
|
-249,278
|
-279,638
|
-299,572
|
-339,900
|
-380,404
|
|
|
Profit from operations
|
59,943
|
45,614
|
52,963
|
61,158
|
65,981
|
78,867
|
89,670
|
|
|
Other
|
3,246
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
1,645
|
|
|
Profit before tax
|
63,189
|
47,259
|
54,608
|
62,803
|
67,626
|
80,512
|
91,315
|
|
|
Tax
|
-19,597
|
-6,820
|
-13,652
|
-15,701
|
-16,907
|
-20,128
|
-22,829
|
|
|
Profit for the year
|
43,592
|
40,439
|
40,956
|
47,102
|
50,720
|
60,384
|
68,486
|
|
|
Average Number of Shares
|
1,265,237
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
1,266,624
|
Terminal Value
|
|
EPS
|
3.40
|
3.20
|
3.23
|
3.72
|
4.00
|
4.77
|
5.41
|
289.25
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Discounted value
|
307.60
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Current Price
|
270.5
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Margin of Safety
|
14%
|
Debt
One final note before concluding; ARM carries with it no long
term debt. Except for some short term trade liabilities the company
is debt free. This means that there are no interest payments to
hinder the company's ability to generate its cash flow. This makes
for a remarkably safe company.
Conclusion
By buying ARM at its current price, you are buying a strong
company, with no debt, good growth and high earnings and cash flow
on nearly no capital expenditures. You're buying a company that is
able to consistently produce cash flow with very little solvency
risk and buying a company, that in the near term is protected from
competition. You are also buying into the smart phone hype, the
iPad hype, the e-book hype and very likely will be buying into the
portable 3D game system hype. If just a few of these 'hypes' meet
their expectations, ARM should continue to see growth and excess
returns.
Disclosure:
I have a small position in ARM
See also
Independents Discover an Attractive Natural Gas
Investment Model
on seekingalpha.com