Tax Inversion: Boon for Firms & Investors, Bane for U.S. Treasury - Analyst Blog

By
A A A

The US federal government may be threatened to lose billions of dollars in revenues. A joint congressional committee on taxation estimates the U.S. Treasury may lose $19.5 billion over the next decade. On the other hand, the corporate houses, which may include some of your favorite stocks, are strategically well placed to save those billion bucks. The common reason for these is Tax inversion. 

Simply put, this latest trend is US corporate houses acquiring offshore companies in nations that offer a lower tax rates. By acquiring the foreign companies, these US firms are shifting their legal homes and thereby chopping the tax bills. 

The global merger & acquisition (M&A) activity clocked a seven-year high. Recurrent foreign acquisitions by U.S. companies indicate that tax inversion is one of the major reasons behind the spike. The tax rate is the highest in the US and thus it is logical for the US firms to find alternative sources whereby they can limit their tax burden. 

No matter what it costs to the exchequer, trimming the tax burden will eventually help the US firms have more cash in their pocket. This additional cash along with advantages like boosting a product portfolio or adding skilled workforce through acquisitions should help these firms do better. Eventually, this should get reflected in their stock prices as well.  

What Is Tax Inversion?

Medtronic, Inc.'s ( MDT ) $42.9 billion acquisition of its Irish competitor in surgical technologies and global healthcare major Covidien plc ( COV ) is a good example of the tax inversion process. The deal was an effort to offset the impact of high U.S. corporate tax rate by shifting Medtronic's tax base overseas.

A tax inversion involves the acquisition of a foreign company and subsequently adopting its home country's domicile. Alternatively, the combined entity can create a holding company in a country where tax rate is lower.

Healthcare Sector Taps Most of the Opportunity

We note that the trend of tax inversion has been mostly prevalent in the healthcare sector. Medical devices and pharma companies are rapidly buying foreign competitors. It is usually easier for a large corporation to purchase small companies than to develop new drugs indigenously. Also, the market for drugs is truly global. Thus the advantages are huge in addition to offloading the tax burden.

Many large US pharma companies already have considerable international revenue base. Tax inversion will further increase their international presence. A strong European pharma sector also makes for several potential targets.

Apart from Medtronic, Mylan, Inc. ( MYL ), Actavis plc ( ACT ), Perrigo Company ( PRGO ), Salix Pharmaceuticals Ltd. ( SLXP ) and Jazz Pharmaceuticals ( JAZZ ) are among the other players in the pharma space reaping the benefits. (Read: Pharma, Biotech M&As Heat Up: Tax Inversion in Focus )

US Charges Highest Tax, UK a Favored Spot

One cannot completely blame the US firms for looking for opportunities to evade taxes in US. According to Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, the combined tax rate (including federal corporate income tax and estimates for state and local rates) in US is 39.1%. That is the highest among the OECD nations. 

On the other side of the pond, UK offers a 21% tax rate. Ireland is the lowest with a tax rate of 12.5% while Slovenia, Poland and Hungary follows with rates of 17%, 19% and 19%, respectively. 

The 21% tax rate in UK is attractive to many of the US firms. Moreover, the location, language and lifestyle in Britain is also drawing the interest of American firms. Robert Willens, corporate tax adviser, told The Wall Street Journal that "Right now, it's safe to say that the U.K. is the preferred country of destination for inverted companies, given the favorable tax regime and the non-tax attractions of the U.K."

The best example here is AbbVie Inc.'s ( ABBV ) move to shift its legal home to UK.

AbbVie-Shire Acquisition: The Biggest on the Block?

Fueling debate on the tax inversion, AbbVie and Shire ( SHPG ) reached an agreement last week for the proposed acquisition of the latter. Not only the tax exemption, but a boost to the product portfolio is seen as one of the advantages of the deal. Valued at approximately $54.5 billion, the AbbVie-Shire deal features among the top 50 inversions to take place in the last 10 years. (Read: AbbVie Set to Acquire UK-Based Shire in Q4 )

Chicago-based AbbVie is expected to trim its overall effective tax rate from 13% in 2016 from 22.6% last year by reincorporating in British island of Jersey. The popular tax-haven Jersey has a 0% standard corporate tax rate.

Mylan, Walgreen Join the Strategy

Mylan's $5.3 billion all stock deal with Abbott Laboratories ( ABT ) also emphasized an increasingly important driver of M&A activity this year. Mylan will become part of the new company, organized in Netherlands. The deal will help Mylan cut its tax rate to 20-21% in the first full year and thereafter to high teens. The deal is expected to result in over $200 million in pre-tax operational efficiencies by the end of third year. 

Walgreen Co. ( WAG ) too is being made a part of the strategy. Walgreen had bought a 45% equity interest in Alliance Boots GmbH for $6.7 billion. Starting Feb 2, 2015, it may purchase the remaining 55% over a six-month period. Reportedly, Walgreen's investors have been demanding the drug retailer to shift base to Europe, again to cut the corporate tax burden.

Obama: Unpatriotic Tax Loophole

Given the flurry of such deals that may cost the government billions of greenbacks, President Obama has now stepped in and termed the inversions as "unpatriotic tax loophole." The President is believed to have urged Congress to pass a legislation that would restrict domestic companies from saving taxes by shifting legal bases to other nations. 

The Obama administration's proposed legislation carries the effective date as Jan 1, 2015. However, Jack Lew, the US Treasury Secretary wants it to be made retroactive to May 2014.

In fact, in a journal for accountants and tax lawyers, Tax Notes, former Treasury official Stephen Shay noted that Obama may invoke a 1969 tax law. The White House may fix the loophole without congressional approval.

Jacob Lew: Reform the Business Tax Code

Secretary Lew is also focused on the tax inversion trend and believes that Congress needs to emphasize banning the inversions and then look into reforms. He said: "It is so important that we reform our business tax code to make the U.S. economy more competitive and to accelerate economic growth and job creation…

"But one particular tax loophole has become increasingly urgent to address: the fact that the law rewards U.S. corporations with substantial tax benefits when they buy foreign companies and declare that they are based overseas."

The White House is said to be not against mergers, but they need to be for economic efficiency rather than being an escape route from paying higher taxes.

Jacob Lew believes tax reforms will still have opportunities for US firms to find countries 'with near-zero rates.' "By moving their tax homes overseas, these companies are making the decision to reduce their taxes, forcing a greater share of the responsibility of maintaining core public functions on small businesses and hardworking Americans," he said. 

"Our tax system should not reward U.S. companies for giving up their U.S. citizenship, and unless we tackle this problem, these transactions will continue," said Lew.

Nobel laureate economist Paul Krugman too has been critical of tax inversion. He said that US firms are "shirking their civic duty" through inversion deals.

A Boost for the Stock Prices 

Mergers themselves boost investors' returns. Stock prices usually go up on acquisition news. Through this year we have seen even the broader indices moving up on several instances following acquisition news. Around mid-February, Actavis plc ( ACT ) agreeing to acquire Forest Laboratories Inc. bolstered the latter's shares by 27.5% while Actavis' shares were up 5%.

Also in late February, Jos. A. Bank Clothiers, Inc. shares surged 9.1% after The Men's Wearhouse, Inc. ( MW ) agreed to increase the cash tender offer for Jos. TriQuint Semiconductor's ( TQNT ) merger with RF Micro Devices, Inc. ( RFMD ) boosted their shares by 26.1% and 21%, respectively.

Later in April, AstraZeneca PLC's ( AZN ) shares surged 12.2% after Pfizer Inc. ( PFE ) confirmed their interest to takeover AstraZeneca for about $100 billion. This was Pfizer's second attempt. Shares of Furiex Pharmaceuticals, Inc. soared 28.6% following Forest Laboratories agreeing to buy the company.

Shares of Pinnacle Foods Inc. ( PF ) surged 13.2% during mid-May when The Hillshire Brands Company ( HSH ) agreed to buy Pinnacle Foods for about $4.3 billion.

Moreover, when one adds the inversion deals, the advantages are definitely more for investors. As mentioned earlier, more cash in the pocket and higher profits for corporate houses should be reflected in the stock prices as well.

How Can Investors Earn More?

Nonetheless, it is also risky to play the M&A rush and more so the inversion trend. Investors should learn a few tricks before betting their bucks. 

The primary rule should be identifying or focusing on a particular sector. Looking at the inversion trend, the healthcare sector has been the dominant player, reasons for which we already discussed earlier. Here, investors should be focusing on the biotechs and specialty pharmaceutical firms. These firms are more prone to be acquired.

Investors can also take advantage by employing merger arbitrage strategy in their portfolio. This strategy looks to tap the price differential (or spread) between the stock price of the target company after the announcement of its proposed acquisition and the price offered by the acquirer to pay for the stocks of the target company.

Investors should go long on the target or acquired company and short on the acquiring company. Once the deal is completed, shares of the target company will increase to the full deal price (in some cases slightly below the deal price), giving investors a decent profit. (Read: Merger Arbitrage ETFs in Focus on Rising Deal Volume )

Zacks Rank

Among the companies discussed, Salix Pharmaceuticals, Men's Wearhouse, TriQuint Semiconductor and RF Micro Devices current carry a Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy). Medtronic, AstraZeneca PLC and Pinnacle Foods are also favorably ranked as they carry a Zacks Rank #2 (Buy). Actavis, Mylan, Shire, Covidien, Jazz Pharmaceuticals, Pfizer, AbbVie, Abbott Laboratories and Walgreen carry a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). However, we currently have a Zacks Rank #4 (Sell) on Hillshire Brands.


Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

TRIQUINT SEMICO (TQNT): Free Stock Analysis Report

MEDTRONIC (MDT): Free Stock Analysis Report

ASTRAZENECA PLC (AZN): Free Stock Analysis Report

PFIZER INC (PFE): Free Stock Analysis Report

COVIDIEN PLC (COV): Free Stock Analysis Report

RF MICRO DEVICE (RFMD): Free Stock Analysis Report

WALGREEN CO (WAG): Free Stock Analysis Report

ABBOTT LABS (ABT): Free Stock Analysis Report

SALIX PHARM-LTD (SLXP): Free Stock Analysis Report

MYLAN INC (MYL): Free Stock Analysis Report

PERRIGO CO PLC (PRGO): Free Stock Analysis Report

JAZZ PHARMACEUT (JAZZ): Free Stock Analysis Report

SHIRE PLC-ADR (SHPG): Free Stock Analysis Report

ABBVIE INC (ABBV): Free Stock Analysis Report

MACYS INC (M): Free Stock Analysis Report

To read this article on Zacks.com click here.

Zacks Investment Research



The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of The NASDAQ OMX Group, Inc.



This article appears in: Investing , Business , Stocks

Referenced Stocks: TQNT , MDT , AZN , PFE , COV

Zacks.com

Zacks.com

More from Zacks.com:

Related Videos

Stocks

Referenced

Most Active by Volume

270,887,127
    $93.89 unch
225,243,115
  • $40.93 ▼ 2.74%
135,900,109
  • $47.52 ▲ 1.80%
89,467,924
  • $5.35 ▼ 1.11%
85,105,358
  • $16.95 ▼ 0.53%
80,748,539
  • $39.80 ▼ 4.21%
68,491,586
  • $3.57 ▼ 1.79%
62,097,356
  • $100.96 ▼ 0.82%
As of 9/19/2014, 04:15 PM

Find a Credit Card

Select a credit card product by:
Select an offer:
Search
Data Provided by BankRate.com