Oil Prices Make for Profitable ETF Trades: Roger Wiegand
Source: Brian Sylvester of
The Energy Report
Today's retail investors have more options than ever before,
but there is a shortage of practical information on how to
manipulate different investment products, be they ETFs, options
or equities. Enter Roger Wiegand, editor of
In this exclusive interview with
The Energy Report,
Wiegand discusses his methods for energy investment and how to
set tailor-made time and price windows to realize solid
The Energy Report:
Roger, we are still in the early stages of 2012 and gas prices
are near all-time lows, with a barrel of oil bobbing in the
US$100 range. What approach are you employing to make money on
oil without getting burned by gas, given that many names out
there have substantial assets in both commodities?
We have three trades on right now. Our futures trade is an oil
spread where we buy a window of opportunity on price, which
allows investors to fix their positions according to their own
price constraints and risk comfort levels. We are looking for an
oil futures price to high of $120 a barrel (bbl) for May to June
of this year. Oil is around $100.60/bbl and there is very good
support for oil right now. Over the years, we have found that oil
will move in a trading range of $4 increments. We are in the
middle of those increments now. I call it $98.50-102.50/bbl. As
the cycle and the calendar move forward, we are looking for a
high of $115-120/bbl for the first half of 2012.
For share traders, we have two positions in stocks, both
exchange-traded funds (ETFs). One is ProShares Ultra DJ-UBS Crude
Oil ETF (UCO:NYSE.A), and the other is Horizons BetaPro NYMEX
Crude Oil Bull Plus ETF (HOU:TSX). The UBS Crude Oil ETF is a
double-long position ETF on oil, meaning that if oil went up $1,
investors would earn $2 on this particular trade. The Horizons
BetaPro NYMEX, a bull-long ETF, is much the same. Normally, when
we recommend a share in our letter, either an ETF or a company,
our objective is to make +25% in 90 days. We can't always do it,
but we do quite well.
You trade all manner of ETFs: gold ETFs, oil ETFs and even a
Canadian dollar ETF. Why do you find these instruments so
appealing and what did you do before ETFs existed?
Before ETFs, we would trade companies, using options and/or
spreads on currencies and futures. It is very handy for a
shareholder to buy an ETF because investors are basically buying
an index or a bundle. Some of these holdings offer very
attractive leverage; I like the ones that are x2 or x3.
One warning I would give is that there are so many ETFs on the
market now that they are becoming diluted. We used to trade SPDR
Gold Shares ETF (GLD:NYSE) for gold and iShares Silver Trust (
) (SLV:NYSE), but we do not recommend them any longer because
they do not move as they did before. Other kinds of trades can
give us a better position. SPDR Gold Shares and iShares Silver
Trust have become elephants and it takes a lot of buying to
But, we are happy with our oil ETFs, and we like the Canadian
dollar ETF because it is a way to park money in Canada, which we
feel is a much better place than the U.S. dollar. Canada is a
commodities-driven country and the Canadian dollar is strong with
good underpinnings. We featured it a year or two ago in our
newsletter and the traders that opted into it are now up over
+20%. We also see the Canadian dollar going to 108.00 on the
index. It is at about 100.48 right now.
There is quite a media buzz about ETFs, but many retail investors
do not have a thorough understanding of how best to trade them.
Could you outline some must-have information for retail investors
looking to play?
Take the oil ETF, USB Crude Oil, for example. It is a double-long
on oil. Normally what will happen with oil in the first half of
any year is that it will start out slowly, go to a peak, then
correct. There will be a correction when the refineries change
over from heating oil to gasoline for the summer. If you can find
two good long positions during the year-normally January to May,
and September to November/December-and if you have a modest goal
of making 25% within 90 days, each of those segments work quite
well. You can do the same thing with gold. We have grain and corn
ETFs too. The objective is to match up the ETF's price, buy it at
the low and try to make 25%. Keep in mind those trades must fit
the calendar cycles.
What is the downside risk to ETFs?
We do not look at gold and silver ETFs, but in our opinion-and I
cannot prove it-the gold ETF does not have 100% of gold behind it
for every share. If things got really dicey in the gold market,
and they could as it is very volatile, there might be some
difficulty in getting out quickly enough on an exit. There are
probably better trades that you can work with to do that. The
NYSE AMEX (NYSE.A) exchange lists the ETFs-you'd be amazed at the
number available. People like them because they do not have to
pick a company; you can just buy a market index sector, but some
of these sectors will sit and not move. Sometimes an ETF or an
index will only move modestly when the overall sector is moving a
lot. You have to be careful.
As far as determining a good entry point for futures or
stocks, you can take the high and low, add them together and
divide by two. That will give you the mean and the point where
you can match price with the calendar and decide where it could
go from there. We get spots on the calendar during the year when
we are too high on a lot of gold and silver stocks and, while we
like the companies, you must consider the amount of potential
movement to make money. If we can see only a movement of 5% or
10%, we will not take it. If somebody wants to buy it, we will
say okay, but hold it and understand that there could be a couple
of pullbacks before it goes up to the next price.
Do you expect oil to outperform gold in 2012 in terms of
It is hard to tell because the gold price is getting quite large.
But consider that gold pretty much gave us 15+% for a whole
decade from about 2000 to 2010. In the last couple of years, the
return has been more like 17-18%. If you use leverage and spreads
the way we do, and if you are a good stock picker, you can do
better than that. We have had some stocks that we have been in
and out of four or five times that have made 50, 60 and 100%
every time. That is why in our letter you will see a lot of
stocks that are negative right now being recommended at previous
highs, but people need to understand that those who have been
reading the letter for a long time have purchased those companies
maybe two, three or four times and made some excellent gains.
Natural gas prices are in the doldrums. How long do you expect it
will be before gas prices begin to stabilize above $4 per
trillion cubic feet? (tcf)
It will be a while because of oversupply. About two years ago,
two major natural gas wells were discovered in Louisiana. One
thing that will push gas up in the summer is air conditioning
demand. Air conditioning demand will cause power companies
running power plants on natural gas to burn quite a bit more.
What will happen then is the gas price will go up. We have been
lingering at around $2.35-$2.50/tcf. It probably should go up
maybe $0.25-0.30/tcf for the summer, but I cannot really see gas
going back to $4-5/tcf for quite some time.
That is unfortunate. What are some other ways that you have
exposure to oil in terms of equities?
One of the other things you can do is buy options on big oil
companies. With some of the biggest ones, if you understand the
calendar and the way their stock price moves within a window, you
can buy an option for $1.50-2.50 and within 90 days, it will
usually return 100%. They seem to work pretty well.
How do you know when to get in and out?
Again, that is the calendar. For example, say that you have Exxon
Mobil Corp. (XOM:NYSE) stock. It has about $45 million (
) in cash in the bank. It is at a point where they are not
spending a lot on exploration right now. They take cash and buy
entire exploration companies, or entire major, proven energy
fields, which is easier. Suppose we think that within a calendar
window of about 120 days, a company has the chance to bypass
performance and go up +$20. What we would try to do is look at
our call option that would be close to being in the money, and
buy one at the money or slightly above it for $1.50-2. Then, when
the stock price rises up, the option goes up in value. Those have
worked out pretty well. We had many of them, not only in energy,
but also in gold and silver and precious metals companies like
Goldcorp Inc. (G:TSX; GG:NYSE) and others in 2006 and 2007. The
volatility and changing markets will go in and out as far as your
ability to do this. We have been away from that opportunity for a
while, but it is starting to come back again. Trading and
investing strategies are in constant change.
How do you respond to someone who says, "I don't trust newsletter
writers because they often get shares in exchange for
I have heard that before. The answer for my newsletter is that I
do NOT trade any of the shares, which is purely deliberate on my
part. For ethical reasons, I do not want to be recommending
shares or ETFs or anything related to shares and then buying them
myself. Now, newsletter writers can do that legitimately. The
good ones I do know, who do it legitimately, will make a
recommendation and buy it themselves 10 days later. And, when
they put out an order to sell it, they wait 10 days and then sell
their position. Obviously, there is going to be some influence.
All of us in this business know the miners, the companies and the
officers. What I look at, being a technician, is if the stock
does not move, I do not want it. Periodically, we will get one
that is a good company but, for whatever reason, it just sits
Can we discuss equities? What are some of your positions in the
It is not in the letter right now, but we do like to trade Exxon
because it is easy to trade. Some of the refinery companies such
as Valero Energy Corp. (VLO:NYSE) and a couple of other ones have
not done that well right now because the refining business is
I would suggest that if readers are looking to buy shares in
an oil company right now, one thing they can do is go toward the
explorers. We have one good explorer in New Zealand Energy Corp.
(NZ:TSX.V; NZERF:OTCQX). New Zealand Energy hit a big well. Its
activities are confined primarily to the country of New Zealand,
and it has done a tremendous job. This well is producing 550
barrels a day. It has a second well being drilled right now and
their stock just took off like a rocket when the well came in. If
you can find the right one, it is a wonderful thing to be an
How did you learn about that particular company?
I was referred to it by a radio friend of mine who bought it. I
looked at the chart and the website and studied it, and it looked
like a super opportunity.
What is the chart telling you now?
The chart paused because it had a big ride in the value of the
shares with that well coming in. There was a little bit of a
pullback, but we are seeing what I call a continuation triangle
in the chart right now. The chances of the next well coming in
appear to be pretty good. We like the company and the management.
We think that when that second well comes in, it will go up quite
a bit more.
On its website, the company says it has the stated goal of being
the largest independent oil producer in New Zealand. As you have
said to me in the past, you set a goal of making 100% every year.
Do you like the fact that this is a lofty goal?
Absolutely. It is hard to make 100% on a stock. The stocks where
we have done so have usually been gold and silver. But this
particular oil stock has been absolutely great from the
standpoint of those who got in on the ground floor. There was
some profit taking because it made so much money in a short
period of time regarding the news on that first well. But the
second well is starting up and I am fairly positive it will do
well. You can buy the shares and hold the stock, although with
some of these juniors, you are probably better off if you do not.
It does have risk. It is a junior exploring company and its
future is based on oil discovery, but now it is in a position
where it has five more wells on the schedule. It is generating
cash flow and preparing to drill another one. And, it has five
major permits right now with multiple wells planned for 2012. I
would say the chances are fairly good for another well to come in
and then the stock would go higher.
A good junior oil explorer is hard to find because they are
quite risky. We had one about six years ago with good managers
and a lot of cash-a well in Wyoming, I believe. It was straddling
a land position between two big wells that were operating-one
with Exxon and one with Marathon Oil Corp. (MRO: NYSE). They were
operating 50 miles apart and this one was right in the middle. It
looked good and the stock was about $2.50 when we recommended a
buy. The promotion was heavy on it and even though it had not
really hit a well, the stock went almost to $7. My concern was if
it came up dry, the stock would make a big reverse. So I walked
people up using risk exit points and we got all the way to $6 and
change. Then an announcement came that they were going to delay
drilling. I told people to sell it. For some reason, they never
drilled the well and the price went all the way back. But, my
people were in from $2.50 to more than $6 based on a strategy
that I devised to protect their position. I told everybody, "If
the well comes in, you can buy it again at about $7.50 on the
charts." But we elected to get out at $6.50.
Any parting thoughts in the energy space as far as what retail
investors should expect for this year?
Natural gas is going to be flat. I would leave that one alone.
The most opportunity for junior stocks is in the explorers. We
can trade call options based on inflation and share prices rising
in some of the seniors. That would really pretty much cover the
yard as far as opportunity this year. Also, there is this Iranian
question that is wide open. I do not think the Straits of Hormuz
will be blocked, but the threats do so create a premium of $5-10
in the oil price. I think that premium pretty much went away as
things calmed down, but it still could be as high as $5 and move
up to $10. That premium is above the fundamental value of the
shares themselves. I think inflation in the U.S. right now is
running at 11.5%. They claim it is almost nonexistent, but that
is not true. If you want to see good inflation numbers, look in
the little box where they report in the
Wall Street Journal
commodities over a one year span and today's prices. The
differences are very dramatic.
Roger Wiegand is the editor of
a newsletter based in Maspeth, N.Y. that provides investors
with short-term buy-and-sell recommendations and commentary on
political and economic factors that are driving the market. He
can be reached at www.tradertracks.com or
. Contact Linda Gorman at Resource Consultants for information on
Roger Wiegand's Technical & Fundamental Trading Class in
Tempe, Arizona on April 26, 2012. Wiegand is also speaking at the
annual Wealth Conference at the same location April 27-28 along
with five other nationally known speakers. Call Linda Gorman at
800-494-4149 or 480-820-5877 for information and
Want to read more exclusive
interviews like this? Sign up for our free e-newsletter, and
you'll learn when new articles have been published. To see a list
of recent interviews with industry analysts and commentators,
visit our Exclusive Interviews page.
1) Brian Sylvester of
The Energy Report
conducted this interview. He personally and/or his family own
shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview:
2) The following companies mentioned in the interview are
The Energy Report:
New Zealand Energy Corp. Streetwise Reports does not accept stock
in exchange for services.
3) Roger Wiegand: I personally and/or my family own shares of the
following companies mentioned in this interview: None. I
personally and/or my family am paid by the following companies
mentioned in this interview: None. I was not paid by Streetwise
for this interview. As reported above, Roger Wiegand does not
personally trade any shares but trades futures and commodities
for his own account. His personal trades are posted in Trader
Tracks Newsletter available by subscription. Contact Claudio
Basis, 718-457-1426 to sign-up.
The Energy Report
is Copyright © 2012 by Streetwise Reports LLC. All rights are
reserved. Streetwise Reports LLC hereby grants an unrestricted
license to use or disseminate this copyrighted material (i) only
in whole (and always including this disclaimer), but (ii) never
The Energy Report does not render general or specific
investment advice and does not endorse or recommend the business,
products, services or securities of any industry or company
mentioned in this report.
From time to time, Streetwise Reports LLC and its
directors, officers, employees or members of their families, as
well as persons interviewed for articles on the site, may have a
long or short position in securities mentioned and may make
purchases and/or sales of those securities in the open market or
Streetwise Reports LLC does not guarantee the accuracy or
thoroughness of the information reported.
Streetwise Reports LLC receives a fee from companies that are
listed on the home page in the In This Issue section. Their
sponsor pages may be considered advertising for the purposes of
18 U.S.C. 1734.
Participating companies provide the logos used in The Energy
Report. These logos are trademarks and are the property of the
101 Second St., Suite 110
Petaluma, CA 94952
Tel.: (707) 981-8204
Fax: (707) 981-8998