Middle East ETFs: More Different Than You Might Think - ETF News And Commentary

By
A A A

If there is one region of the world where investors can usually agree on the economic fundamentals, it has to be the Middle East. The area is world-famous for its hydrocarbon prowess, relatively high GDP per capita levels, and as of late, its political volatility as well.

Given the immense potential that these countries have thanks to their fossil fuel exports and how they are transforming their economies for the long term, parts of the region could be ripe for investment for those with a long time horizon and a stomach for volatility. Unfortunately, the region remains relatively closed-off from an investment perspective as few ADRs trade here in the States while other options are sparse to say the least.

However, there are a few exchange-traded funds that can make for interesting ways to target the region with a diversified, and thus lower risk, approach. Currently, there are two ETFs that offer direct exposure to this important region of the world, the WisdomTree Middle East Dividend Fund ( GULF ) and the Market Vectors Gulf States Index ETF ( MES ) .

Since many investors view the region as a monolithic economy, in which the entire area is completely dependent on fossil fuels for growth, it might be assumed that there is virtually no difference between these two Middle East ETFs. Yet, when one takes a look at the return and risk of these products, that is certainly not the case (see The Truth about Low Volume ETFs ).

In fact, according to our research (based on daily price returns from the past three years) MES and GULF have a correlation of just 0.57, suggesting that at least 40% of the time these two products move independently of each other, despite the fact that they track substantially similar countries. This is somewhat shocking at first glance as both target similar firms as well, although when one dives deeper into the holdings, it becomes clearer that these two Middle East ETFs are more different than you might have originally thought.

First, investors should note that MES tracks the Dow Jones GCC Titans 40 index. This benchmark focuses exposure on Gulf Cooperation Council nations, offering up exposure to some of the richest-but also smallest nations-in the world (Read Small Cap Value ETF Investing 101 ).

Meanwhile, GULF, despite its ticker, has a broader geographic range but a narrower security focus, thanks to tracking the WisdomTree Middle East Dividend Index. This benchmark, unsurprisingly, holdings dividend paying stocks from around the Middle East, including a 10% allocation to Egypt.

Still, despite various geographic focuses, investors should note that both put their top three allocations into the same nations of Qatar, the UAE, and Kuwait. In both cases, these three make up more than two-thirds of the total assets, suggesting that despite the different security stipulations, both are zeroing in on the same nations for their exposure (see Five Great Global ETFs for Complete Equity Exposure ).

Yet despite this national similarity, the asset allocation is pretty different for the two products. Financials (43%), telecom (31%), and industrials (15%) comprise the bulk of the assets in GULF, while in MES, financials (58%) make up a majority, leaving much less for telecoms (15%) and industrials (12%).

So clearly, the holdings picture accounts for much of the difference between these two seemingly similar funds. Additionally, GULF's dividend focus surprisingly gives the fund less of a concentration in financials, although it does help to boost the fund's yield over its Van Eck counterpart.

These differences are also part of the reason for the wildly divergent performances between the two ETFs so far in 2012. Since the start of the year, MES has added about 5.8% while GULF has retreated over 1.1% in the same time frame (read Will the Egypt ETF Be Crushed By More Turmoil? ).

Meanwhile, in longer time periods, such as from a two year look, MES maintains its lead over GULF although both have gained in that time period (MES leads by about 240 basis points). However, it is also important to remember that MES costs ten basis points more per year and pays out roughly 70 basis points less in yield, suggesting that much of the return differential can be eaten up by these two factors.

Either way, it appears that while MES and GULF appear quite similar at first glance, these are actually two very different funds. It is true that they both focus on the Middle East region but they do it in very different ways, neither of which seem likely to be appropriate for all investors in every situation.  Once again, the adage of 'know what is in your ETF' is proven true (see Three Biggest Mistakes of ETF Investing ).

Clearly, you cannot rely on a fund's name or geographic focus in order to assume that two similarly named funds will perform the same. After all, if this can happen in the case of the Middle East, where returns are nearly universally driven by oil and investment of hydrocarbon dollars, it can definitely happen in other corners of the ETF world, suggesting that a close inspection of the underlying holdings is vital no matter what market segment you are looking into.

 

 

MES

GULF

Expense Ratio

0.98%

0.88%

Biggest Sector

Financials- 58%

Financials- 43%

Biggest Nation

Kuwait- 39%

Qatar- 30%

Dividend Yield (annual)

3.85%

4.55%

Egypt Exposure?

0%

10%

YTD Return

+5.8%

-1.15%

Beta (against S&P 500 last 3yrs)

.59

0.50

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days . Click to get this free report >>


 
WISDMTR-ME DIV (GULF): ETF Research Reports
 
MKT VEC-GULF ST (MES): ETF Research Reports
 
To read this article on Zacks.com click here.
 
Zacks Investment Research
 
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report



The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of The NASDAQ OMX Group, Inc.



This article appears in: Investing , ETFs

Referenced Stocks: GULF , MES

Zacks.com

Zacks.com

More from Zacks.com:

Related Videos

Stocks

Referenced

Most Active by Volume

112,131,130
  • $74.98 ▲ 5.18%
57,963,905
  • $8.32 ▲ 8.33%
48,392,602
  • $3.45 ▼ 0.29%
45,276,527
  • $36.17 ▲ 4.21%
44,800,927
  • $17.84 ▲ 0.34%
44,539,649
  • $97.03 ▼ 0.16%
44,078,180
  • $15.62 ▲ 0.64%
43,461,551
  • $35.50 ▼ 1.06%
As of 7/24/2014, 04:04 PM