Shares of struggling tech giant Hewlett-Packard (NYSE:
) have fallen precipitously on Wednesday after the company
slashed its outlook for the fiscal year. At the company's annual
Securities Analyst Meeting, Hewlett-Packard president and CEO Meg
Whitman said that she expects the company's revenues to be
growing in line with GDP by 2016, with operating profit growing
faster than revenues.
For fiscal 2013, Hewlett-Packard sees EPS between $3.40 and
$3.60. This is well below current Wall Street consensus estimates
The stock began falling sharply immediately after this updated
guidance and at last check, HPQ was down more than 9 percent to
$15.48. Volume has been extremely heavy with more than 81 million
shares trading hands compared to a 3-month daily average of 21.5
The stock has been under significant pressure for a number of
years now and over the last 5 years, shares are down 69 percent.
Most of those losses have come since the beginning of 2011.
Year-to-date, HPQ has shed 40 percent.
Many value-oriented managers have been burned in this name as
HPQ is a leading technology brand which is trading at a cheap
valuation. The company's fundamentals, particularly in its PC
business, however, have been deteriorating on a consistent basis.
In sum, HPQ has become the prototypical value trap.
Many high profile hedge fund managers have attempted to make
money on this battleground stock on both the long and short side.
For example, noted value investor Seth Klarman's Baupost Group
showed a $540 million position in the stock at the end of the
second quarter. Clearly, the sharp decline in the shares on
Wednesday is going to be painful for Baupost and other value
investors involved in this name.
On the other end of the spectrum are short-sellers such as Jim
Chanos' Kynikos Associates which has a high profile bet against
the company. On the surface, shorting HPQ is a difficult trade.
For one, this is a diversified technology company with a
preeminent brand and a deeply established business. It is also
seemingly very cheap. The stock trades at a forward P/E of under
In the tech industry, however, when things go bad and revenues
start plunging, usually as a result of an inability to compete
and innovate at the forefront of the pack, share prices can
collapse in a hurry. Investors have numerous examples to draw
from in order to analyze this phenomenon. Two companies that
immediately come to mind are Research in Motion (NASDAQ:
) and Palm, which was actually acquired by Hewlett-Packard.
Today's news does little to discourage the perception on Wall
Street that HPQ has become, unfortunately, another tech dinosaur
in need of a radical overhaul. Without a fundamental
restructuring of the business and the brand, this company may be
destined for extinction, succumbing to the same fate as so many
once innovative Silicon Valley leaders that couldn't keep pace
with the rapid changes taking place in the tech marketplace.
While that may seem like an extreme statement, it is not.
Hewlett-Packard isn't cool. It isn't innovative on a sufficient
scale. Its core businesses are deteriorating and its stock price
is in free-fall. The price of the shares has now basically been
halved since hitting $30 in February. The writing is on the wall
for this company, and today's bloodbath, yet again, should be a
warning to investors. Find value somewhere else - like in a
company that is actually succeeding in the current
(c) 2012 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment
advice. All rights reserved.