Emerging Markets Big Picture – It’s just not as easy as saying “Risk On” and “Risk Off” anymore


Shutterstock photo

In a topic which could be discussed at great length beyond this forum, I would at least like to sketch the surface of a concept I think many investors (including me) are having trouble with.

[caption id="attachment_33930" align="alignright" width="240" caption="Tim Seymour"] Tim Seymour [/caption]

Emerging market ( EEM , quote ) equities have vastly underperformed those global equities who are getting their growth largely form emerging markets.

What gives?

Part of the answer lies in what is a long standing precept that commodities have to be rallying for emerging market equities to do well, and that emerging market equities are dominated by state controlled companies where corporate governance is awful.

In the last 18 months commodities have struggled and state controlled emerging market companies have dominated the headlines for their ineptitude. Thus, emerging markets have badly lagged domestic markets (see chart), as U.S. and European multinationals have gone to all-time highs.

Because we are in the month of May, markets are overly consumed with "risk on" and "risk off".

Investment allocation is difficult in a world where commodity prices seem to be signaling one thing but measures of risk say another.  Copper prices are challenging multiyear lows while the Spanish 10yr yield is in 2007 territory and Italy is issuing 2yr paper at all-time lows.

China is grinding lower but U.S. and European indices are at all-time highs.

Is global growth collapsing or is the world healing slowly, with strong pockets of real growth in key parts of the global economy?

Is the move to all-time highs in global equity markets just a run of free money or should investors be even more confident with global growth despite what spot commodity prices are doing?

Yesterday's one brain cell analysis worked and correlations were high between the asset classes.

I often write about deflationary forces of the asset bubble popping and that Fed policy is complicating the road to true healing.  I believe we are living in a world where the pressure on prices for most things (except of course daily "stuff" we seem to consume...) is to move lower.

But the correlation of higher commodities with higher global growth may have started to run its course.   While we are not surfing the wave of the commodity super-cycle go-go days, there is still major demand for copper, ore, steel, and other core commodities.

China will not lead the next phase of global growth, nor will Brazil but there is a housing recovery going on in the U.S. and there are still 5 trillion in Yuan infrastructure projects due to be implemented in China over the next 5 years.

For many of us in emerging markets this has all been a head scratcher as "our stocks" are massively underperforming despite that conditions that emerging markets should generally love:  low inflation, falling rates, consumption growth, albeit slower than it was pre-crisis.  We all may need to adjust our thinking if we have not already done so to stay the course on fundamentals and not be expecting the next May/June disaster for emerging markets.  If global companies like Siemens, GM, Coke, and HSBC can grow with emerging markets as a core driver, maybe it's time to look for even greater returns out emerging market companies who have lagged the move in global markets.

Either way we should be mindful of the following:  lower commodity prices do not necessarily mean risk off, and correlations breaking down is a good thing.   Stay tuned for our Emerging Money Global Index where we highlight the top 30 multinationals operating in emerging markets.

The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

This article appears in: Investing , Stocks

More from Emerging Money


Emerging Money

Emerging Money

Emerging Markets
Follow on:

Find a Credit Card

Select a credit card product by:
Select an offer:
Data Provided by BankRate.com