The gold crash in April shocked investors and likely wiped out
a few trading accounts. Hedge fund god John Paulson reportedly
lost more than $1 billion.
But what if the gold crash didn't surprise every investor?
What if a few powerful people orchestrated it?
Hugo Salinas Price - Wharton grad and president of the Mexican
Civic Association Pro Silver - thinks foul play was involved.
After retiring from the business world, he set out to fix fiscal
policy in Mexico, and is also huge a proponent of investing in
precious metals. He believes that collusion among major banks
helped take the price of gold down by more than 16% in five days.
In fact, Mr. Salinas Price compares this collusion to
psychological operations (PSYOPs) often used by the U.S. Army and
PSYOPs are planned operations to convey selected information and
indicators to audiences to influence their emotions, motives,
objective reasoning and ultimately the behavior of governments,
organizations, groups and individuals. Sounds sinister, doesn't
it? Well, it is.
For years, investors were pushed toward gold as a way to protect
their portfolios from danger. But that tune started to change
about a year ago. Though few banks advised selling gold, analysts
grew less positive despite obvious global turmoil.
Mr. Salinas Price argues that banks were grooming us to avoid
buying gold during the past year as they waited for the right
time to strike by buying tons of gold at lower prices. That time
- according to Mr. Salinas Price - was when the fear of bank runs
in Europe was high.
Normally, that fear would have driven investors into frenzy,
sending gold higher. However, the negative grooming by the banks
kept investors from buying gold during the bank run - or even
after the now famous "
" comments by Dutch politician Jeroen Dijsselbloem.
The banks had successfully made the gold bugs nervous. So
nervous, in fact, that they were thinking of selling at a time
when they would normally be buyers.
Goldman Sachs (
released a report on April 10 that recommended investors sell
gold stakes and take a short position in the metal. Overwhelmed
by emotions, investors acted like a deer in headlights. Most got
run over, while only a few escaped alive.
Commerzbank AG said that 1,100 tons of gold (futures) were sold
on April 12 - that equates to about 45% of the world's supply. By
April 15, gold had fallen 16% and hit a two-year low.
This hysteria - argues Mr. Salinas Price and other gold bulls -
allowed major institutions to buy the metal at low prices.
Though there is some merit to this theory because Goldman
curiously called off their short recommendation on April 23, I'm
not so sure that I'm ready to claim collusion. Moreover, I don't
think major market participants intentionally used PSYOPs to
drive investors out of gold during the past year.
True, something does smell fishy. Goldman and other banks likely
profited from a decline in gold prices they promoted. And some
may have used that high-volume selling as another opportunity to
It's also suspicious that Goldman would flip-flop so quickly.
However, analysts are allowed to change their stance whenever
they deem fit. Moreover, analysts at times are going to be wrong.
How many analysts predicted
was worth $1,000 last year? And what are they saying now?
Mr. Salinas Price is entitled to his opinion, but the recent
decline in gold prices isn't a case of collusion. Inflation is
not picking up in the way most investors anticipated it would.
Moreover, yields have been climbing. Gold typically performs best
when 10-year yields are lower than the inflation rate.
However, we both agree that gold prices will likely move higher
over the next several years. Inflation cannot remain below 3% for
an extended period, especially as employment improves. Since
Bernanke is not going to raise rates soon, the gap between
inflation and yields will widen, pushing the price of gold and
other precious metals higher.
Where do you think gold will be in a year? Do you think the banks
conspired against investors to bring the price of gold down? I'd
love to hear your thoughts. Please leave a comment below.